Too Dorothy?

Brutally Honest Mondays” border=

Photobucket

Photobucket

Okay, I bought these shoes on Friday and adored them at the time.  They are red, YES!  But, they aren’t too lady-of-the-night red or Dorothy there’s-no-place-like-home red.  I also thought the detailing on the shoes was especially cute.  Now though, I still LOVE them, but I’m kinda worried that when I wear them people are going to notice ONLY my shoes and not my winning personality and witty conversational skills.

These shoes were bought on the intention of wearing them to this little conference I’m attending next week, where I *might* meet some other women who I would like to impress.  I don’t want to overhear anyone say, “Oh my, poor girl!  Did you SEE her shoes?!  What WAS she thinking?!”

I plan on wearing these shoes with dark wash jeans and a either black or brown shirts.   Stacy and Clinton tell people that it’s okay to add a punch of color with THEIR shoes.   Can I?  Should I?

Please be honest…Yay or nay on the shoes? 

PS.  I bought these shoes at Payless…does that make a difference?

Share with others
  • StumbleUpon
  • TwitThis
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Google
  • Kirtsy
  • LinkedIn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • blogmarks
  • YahooMyWeb

123 Responses to “Too Dorothy?”

  1. I think they are super cute - and would look great with dark jeans. My problem with shoes like that is I never know what to do with the sock situation - socks or no socks - and if socks - what kind/color/pattern/no pattern!?!?!?!

    McCathys last blog post..Another To Do List

    Reply to this comment
  2. As long as you don’t pair them with a light blue apron or dress I say Yeah! They will look great with dark wash jeans.

    T with Honeys last blog post..I’m funny, at least in my own mind

    Reply to this comment
  3. cute! wear ‘em with pride.

    Mama DBs last blog post..Gorgeous Weekend & Anniversary

    Reply to this comment
  4. HELL YES, it’s okay to wear those shoes! They’re both adorable and fabulous. :-)

    And I want them.

    Sarcastic Moms last blog post..Age of Aquarius

    Reply to this comment
  5. I think you could totally rock them. I love red shoes.

    Reply to this comment
  6. Adorable.
    And I say this because I have a pair almost exactly like that. ;-)
    I won’t tell you the part where my 4 year old calls them my Dorothy shoes. Promise.

    Mandys last blog post..Glamour is a scarf

    Reply to this comment
  7. love them
    I love red shoes
    go girl

    amys last blog post..Show ‘em how we do it

    Reply to this comment
  8. I’d wear them. I would listen to Stacy and Clinton. They know their stuff. I actually think I may need to go out and get them too.

    Lauras last blog post..71: Traditional Argentine BBQ: The Asado

    Reply to this comment
  9. red shoes are a wardrobe necessity!
    and totally HOT!

    alis last blog post..that’s what she said, i don’t like boats, and i have problems

    Reply to this comment
  10. They are adorable!!! Everyone needs a pair of cute red shoes. And Stacy and Clinton know their shit - so go for it!

    amys last blog post..I Cheated on The Man with The Other Man

    Reply to this comment
  11. Those are SUPER cute! I personally only wear black shoes, but I might consider those ;) That’s how cute they are.

    Beckies last blog post..Wired for Noise is giving away a breast pump!

    Reply to this comment
  12. Those shoes are fabulous! I might have to go get myself a pair.

    They will look awesome with jeans. And if anyone has anything to say behind your back about you and your red shoes, it will only be to spread the word on how darn cute you look.

    Mamaspheres last blog post..Please Welcome To The Family…

    Reply to this comment
  13. As with any Payless purchase, those shoes could be out of style by August and it won’t matter if you only wore them once, they were cheap.
    Then again, I have gotten stuff at Payless that I fully intended would only be useful once and have turned into my favorite pair of shoes.

    PS) If you do want glittery red no-place-like-home shoes, there are some at Target, my daughter has a pair. You might have to go down a size or two to squeeze into ‘em though.

    Reply to this comment
  14. Yay on the shoes. Very cute!

    Headless Moms last blog post..July 4, 2007

    Reply to this comment
  15. I love those shoes, I have almost the same exact pair (also from Payless…) I’ve worn them several times with dark jeans, a black skirt, and khaki pants. Everyone loves them when I wear them.

    I personally love shoes and think the right pair of shoes with the outfit makes someone seem all that more charming and whitty because they took the time and put the effort into finding the right shoe.

    But that’s just me.

    CourtneyRyans last blog post..Thursday Thirteen - Places I’d Like to Visit

    Reply to this comment
  16. Yay on the red shoes! Love Stacy and Clinton! Yay for Payless too, no one will know where you got them, nor do you need to tell!

    Kims last blog post..Little girl, BIG personality

    Reply to this comment
  17. If people are staring at your shoes, just tell them “My eyes are up here buddy!” And you’re one step ahead if you see any evil green women - just click your heels three times. I would be one of the evil green women except I won’t be in SF (hence my green-ness) but even then, I’d think they were great shoes:) Have fun next week.

    Mary Beths last blog post..THE TOP 100 LIST

    Reply to this comment
  18. I’m thinking that I’ll have to run down to payless and see if they have them in my size. They are Cute! And would definately look great with dark jeans. I love red shoes, I have several pairs.

    Karas last blog post..H’s birthday invitations

    Reply to this comment
  19. It has been established that they are cute, but the real question is are the COMFORTABLE? If so, then keep them and wear them with SASS! If not…..take ‘em back. I have bought quite a few pair of colorful cute shoes that were NOT comfy and I have gotten blisters from h-e-l-l, and since they are for your “little conference” you really want them to be comfy. My 2 cents.

    abunslifes last blog post..My Pups Smiled

    Reply to this comment
  20. Super duper cute. I have a few (yes a few) pairs of red shoes. Perfect with black or brown - also adorably cute with denim.

    Teris last blog post..T. Casts On

    Reply to this comment
  21. abunslife, they are surprisingly comfortable! I just can’t do uncomfortable shoes.

    Reply to this comment
  22. I LOVE them. Very cute. And they’ll look fabulous with jeans.

    Renee Daniels aka Indygirls last blog post..It’s official

    Reply to this comment
  23. love em.

    i say wear them with pride. stacy and clinton would be proud.

    and they are from payless!! hello even better!!

    amandas last blog post..red, white and boo hoo

    Reply to this comment
  24. Not only do I love the shoes, I think I’ll be looking for the person wearing those shoes at that little conference. Now, I’m feeling pressure to pick up my own pair of cute little (okay a size 10 isn’t little) shoes, as well.

    califmoms last blog post..Links for 2008-07-06 [del.icio.us]

    Reply to this comment
  25. They are adorable! Have fun at BH!

    Karen Sugarpantss last blog post..Convince Him!

    Reply to this comment
  26. Yay! So cute!

    I think a pair of red shoes is JUST THE THING to spice up dark jeans and a black shirt.

    rimaramas last blog post..I Saw Some Fireworks

    Reply to this comment
  27. They are ADORABLE. I need to find a payless so I can get some. I say jeans and black shirt. Or white if you own such a thing that isn’t stained. (I don’t)

    Devans last blog post..Random city

    Reply to this comment
  28. I likes them! You can so pull that off with a skirt or capris.

    Anglophile Football Fanatics last blog post..Home Again, Home Again, Jiggity Jig

    Reply to this comment
  29. Hmmmmm. My intial instinct is WAY CUTE. However, it’s hard to say w/out seeing them on.

    That said, if I bought these shoes for myself, my mother would HATE them. She thinks the Mary Jane strap cuts your feet off. But what does she know?

    Greta/Does This Blog Make Us Look Fats last blog post..Monday is D-Day…Unless You’re Bin Laden

    Reply to this comment
  30. Aff, you think I can wear them with capris, too? Maybe I’ll get more than one wear out of them after all!

    If anyone else would like to chime in as to whether they could be worn with capris ALSO, let me know!

    Reply to this comment
  31. LOVE them! And whee you bought them makes no difference.

    Devilish Southern Belles last blog post..I’ve been doing so much reading lately

    Reply to this comment
  32. I think they’re great!!

    the dragonflys last blog post..Shoulder to the Wheel

    Reply to this comment
  33. Yes, with jeans and a black shirt! I wouldn’t wear them with capris though - but that might just be me.

    catnips last blog post..a bit of a byte

    Reply to this comment
  34. I had a pair of red wedges that The Hubs affectionately referred to as my hooker shoes. But they were about four inches higher than yours. Yours are cute. And I was totally seeing them with dark jeans and a neutral shirt. Tres chic!

    Insta-Moms last blog post..Counting the days

    Reply to this comment
  35. I’ve owned a pair of gorgeous red flats for a number of years now. I always pair them with jeans/black shirt. It just makes that combo I bit more special. Definitely would work with capris as well!

    Denise @ EatPlayLoves last blog post..Family Camping In Colorado (it could happen)…

    Reply to this comment
  36. The shoes I wear with my tuxedo are from Wal-Mart. Best tux shoes I’ve ever worn.

    I think they are good. Now red high heels would make you look like a hooker. I would go with a black shirt though instead of red.

    Knot

    Knots last blog post..Eye Candy - 07-01-008

    Reply to this comment
  37. I love them. I hope they have them here too. Every girl needs a pair of red mary janes.

    Reply to this comment
  38. Super cute! I want them too. Wear ‘em with pride!

    Beckys last blog post..The 4H Camping trip!

    Reply to this comment
  39. I love them! Red shoes are super cute in my opinion. You’ll probably get lots of compliments on them.

    Reply to this comment
  40. I love red shoes.. I have two pair. Match em with a red purse or a cute red bracelet and you are set.

    Reply to this comment
  41. Not only do I LOVE these shoes, I’m going to find some for myself!!!

    Shellys last blog post..Moving (The End)

    Reply to this comment
  42. Yay! Yay! Yay! And I’m so glad you told us where you got them because I think I need a pair too.

    Jackies last blog post..Sigh.

    Reply to this comment
  43. I have EXACTLY the same shoes, and will be wearing them to BlogHer (I think). So will Loralee (Loralee’s Looney Tunes), Aimee Greeblemonkey and at least one other blogger I saw posting about these shoes!!

    We’re gonna have a club….you in? ;)

    So, ya, I like the shoes.

    VDogs last blog post..Weekly Winners ~ First Week of July

    Reply to this comment
  44. Oh, you could TTY wear them with capris…black or jean ones…maybe khaki?

    I’ve worn them with jeans and a navy dress so far….

    VDogs last blog post..Weekly Winners ~ First Week of July

    Reply to this comment
  45. Hell, Yes!

    I’d definitely wear them with jeans. There is nothing quite like red shoes. One of my favorite colors. You know how they say “blondes have more fun” well I say “women in red shoes have more soul (sole???)”

    Vickis last blog post..Monday, Monday

    Reply to this comment
  46. I am loving them. And yeah I think capris would work. A dark wash jeans or black capris.

    Reply to this comment
  47. You know…I am not a shoe person so I can’t really say. I try not to go anywhere where I can’t where my sneaks. :-P
    Sandys last blog post..I missed this…or is it just the hormones?

    Reply to this comment
  48. Ugh I can NOT talk today. I meant dark jean capris or black capris.
    I need to go back to bed!

    Reply to this comment
  49. they will look rockin’ with the new haircolor, no matter what you wear!

    Reply to this comment
  50. I love those shoes! I tried them on, but they made my feet look stumpy.

    Loris last blog post..Balls, balls and more balls- Part 3

    Reply to this comment
  51. I LOVE them, and

    TAG!!

    mandys last blog post..Everyone wants to kill me…

    Reply to this comment
  52. YAY a thousand times over. Jeans, capris, skirts, a shirt dress … OMG the options are limitless.

    Catherines last blog post..Losing Touch

    Reply to this comment
  53. As a proud owner of 3 red shoes, I am all for them. They are really cute! I think every Cosmo gal needs a pair of red shoes. They tend to make you walk a bit differently. You’ll be strutting in no time!

    Reply to this comment
  54. Definately Dorothy Red…but in a good way. Lady of the night would be if they were stillettos. I think I just botched that word up.

    Reply to this comment
  55. I LOVE them! You should totally wear them with whatever you’d like…dark jeans, black pants, pajama shorts- whatever floats your boat!

    SEriously….I LOVE them! TOTAL YAY on the shoes!!

    Reply to this comment
  56. I say yay! Everyone needs a little dash of color sometimes.

    Yertles last blog post..Which Sports Car Are You?

    Reply to this comment
  57. I love Love LOVE them!!!!

    Kendras last blog post..Great New Pics of the Kids!

    Reply to this comment
  58. Big fat YAY. And now I must depart for Payless. You really should get paid for plugging… oh wait…

    kristis last blog post..Cuteness

    Reply to this comment
  59. Are you sure you have a brown or black shirt? Because I remember pictures of your wardrobe and I just can’t seem to recall any brown or black shirts.

    ;)
    canapes last blog post..You must have the wrong number

    Reply to this comment
  60. LOVE them.

    And I shop at Payless.

    Aimee Greeblemonkeys last blog post..A Call for the Silver Platters to Reunite!

    Reply to this comment
  61. Those shoes are super cute! I would definitely wear them with dark jeans.

    Cassies last blog post..Mr. Grumpypants

    Reply to this comment
  62. I definitely say yes. I have a friend who always dresses in dark jeans and black or white tops with red shoes, and it looks VERY sophisticated. Great choice.

    Ashleys last blog post..Things I love…

    Reply to this comment
  63. Not only am I jealous of your shoes, but I am equally jealous of the fact that you are going to BlogHer. I am SO going next year.

    (stupid birthday.)

    Margarets last blog post..MootchAss GrassyAss, Senyureeter

    Reply to this comment
  64. I love those shoes and may make a trip to payless for my own. I always notice people’s shoes. If they have cute shoes that usually means they are worth getting to know. A little superficial I know.

    Lauren Popps last blog post..I’m not Freaking Out…yet

    Reply to this comment
  65. WEAR THEM! They’re fab, and I’m getting on Payless.com to order some for myself…

    Katies last blog post..I Love the Eighties…

    Reply to this comment
  66. I LOVE THOSE SHOES. And they will now allow the rest of us to find you at BlogHer, kind of like holding a rose on a blind date.

    I bought a cute pair of black slip ons with white polka dots today at Target, for that very same little conference. We’re gonna rock the shoes, baby!

    Reply to this comment
  67. I give them two snaps in z formation!

    Seriously. I heart Payless and wore some Merrell type knockoffs at J&J Camp Baby.

    Love the red. Punch of color indeed hot mama!

    Reply to this comment
  68. Good evening,

    Just found your blog! LOVE those shoes, but more importantly great blogging tips in your archives.

    Thanks!

    Reply to this comment
  69. Love the shoes! I have a great red bag for them…

    Debs last blog post..Summer gardens

    Reply to this comment
  70. I love red in every way - shoes included. And since I have admitted that AND I happen to live in the land of Dorothy, I can say with great authority that they are not too road-to-oz at all. For that they would have to be covered in glitter.

    Maggies last blog post..Best Shot Monday - Success!

    Reply to this comment
  71. DO YOU REALIZE THERE ARE ABOUT 15 OF US WEARING THESE SHOES TO BLOGHER????

    I posted about it and then laughed my ass off from the comments and people emailing me.

    We should TOTALLY organize a “Wear your red payless shoes to this session/cocktail party/keynote speaker” event.

    It.would.be.awesome.

    “I’m wearing red Payless shoes to BlogHer!”

    HEE!

    P.S. The are quickly becoming my favorite shoes.

    Loralees last blog post..Sideblog: BLOG NOSH MAGAZINE

    Reply to this comment
  72. Cute…punch away! Have a blast at Blogher!!! I’ll be here…alone…hello…Is anyone there?

    Nap Wardens last blog post..Don’t Count Out the Old Broads!

    Reply to this comment
  73. Absolutely, wear those shoes. It’s just too bad they’re not patent leather - you know, for the Catholic girls.

    lceels last blog post..Short and sweet

    Reply to this comment
  74. I think they’re tres cute! And getting them from Payless is like a free ticket to throw them out after one season, I think! That’s the excuse I use for buying stuff at cheaper stores. :)

    Reply to this comment
  75. Big ol thumbs up. And the fact that you bought them at payless makes me want to throw in some toes too!

    Jesss last blog post..Living two lives at the same time

    Reply to this comment
  76. Love them!

    I own last year’s red flats from Payless. Very similar, no pleats around the toe. Very wearable too. I have worn then with white capris, kahkis, jeans… And now I’m stalking these ones in black.

    I am a Payless junkie. I am convinced that one day I will be a very successful woman with the world’s largest collection of shoes from Target and Payless.

    Please tell me you know you can get 10% off if you have AAA!

    TheMamas last blog post..Monday Morning Intervention